18 Jun 2018

Pa Ranjith's Rajni Again

Think of a Rajni film and it usually boils down to hyperbole – omnipotent, never with the smallest sign of weakness – invincible! Go on any day (near the release date) to any show of a Rajni film in Tamil Nadu – You are sure to be drowned in whistles, loud intrusive cheering and confetti (sometimes even currency notes!) – fan hysteria comparable in scale remotely only to football mania. Rajni fans are to be found in various shades in the family across generations, some of who went all clad in black for the preview on Thursday before the film was released in India. I grew up enjoying Rajni’s stylish ‘stunts’ but I am not exactly a fan. I have usually preferred Kamal Hassan’s repertoire over Rajni’s repetitive rigmaroles. But that changed with Kabali. Here was a director who could ‘tame’ this superlative superstar’s image into that of a human being. (I also like the way Pa. Ranjith retains the Tamizh way of writing his initials.) He brought to the diehard Rajni fan what she/he wanted to see, even as he gave the discerning audience something unusual in a Rajni film – a decent storyline, a sensitive hero, and deadly symbolism.

The usual opening scene that introduces Rajni in his film is almost James Bond like in its attempt to leverage his mass appeal, but not in Kaala. (And strangely, there was no chest-beating display of emotions from his fans in the audience, no confetti. Just a weak applause, almost an apologetic disturbance of the routine silence expected in the film hall.) Pa. Ranjith gets Rajni to play gully-cricket and at a crucial point in the match, Rajni is clean bowled to a young boy’s bowling. The invincible Superstar is shown as weak and frail in several other scenes as well, throughout the film – taken to jail, made to sit on the floor, asked to fall at the feet of a political leader etc. These scenes are interspersed with several other reminiscent of standard Rajni fare – come out of blazing fire unscathed, survive gunshot wounds with panache etc. Ranjith refuses to feed the crazy, unthinking Rajni fanatic the usual fodder. Rajni cannot take down the powerful establishment single-handedly here. He cannot avenge the loss of his loved ones, all by himself, like he usually does. It is only the people’s support that catapults him into the demi-god status in the film. Without them, he’s vulnerable.

Pa. Ranjith makes caste-based discrimination ooze out of every pore of the film’s skin. The ardent Ram-bhakt who thinks he is ‘born to rule’ like his idol refuses to drink water offered (outside) Kaala’s home. If Kaala’s Karikaalan is named after the local village deity (protector), the villain Haridev is named after Vishnu. If Kaala is usually clad in black or blue (always in a lungi, stylishly worn as a defiant marker of identity in India’s commercial capital), almost deifying BLACK as a symbol of hitting back, Nana Patekar’s character is all clad in white, his home resplendent with white furniture and upholstery, all snowy and ‘pure’ with the stark exception of the black LED TV. When Karikaalan enters this home (after promptly taking off his footwear outside the door!), he drinks the water offered by Haridev’s granddaughter (in contrast to the host who had refused to drink it at his home, possibly due to caste and purity reasons), and disallows her from falling at his feet. Respect for all humans as equals without the demeaning act of paying obeisance is in one stroke a hitting out at casteism, classism and ageism.

Pa. Ranjith’s Dharavi is not Mani Rathnam’s one in ‘Nayagan’. There is no gloss applied. Nothing made palatable for consumption. No euphemisms. It’s crass and crude and black and sooty, like it is. You are made to see it. You are made to feel it, like it is. Iconography is everything for Pa. Ranjith. Periyar, the Buddha and Ambedkar occupy the settings prominently in all the nooks and crannies of Karikaalan’s Dharavi, even as huge political hoardings with Haridev’s photographs (and slogans reminiscent of the ‘Swachh Bharat’ campaign) look down, screaming out his political philosophy – clean and pure Mumbai without the dirty slums of the city. Haridev’s home prominently displays white marble statues of the Ram-Sita-Lakshman triumvirate. The Africa-return NGO-type represented by the clean and suave Zareena has quotations of Wangari Maathai and pictures of herself with her daughter (Who has the Greek word for black, as her name) in a collage on the wall. Flags for the Dharavi masses have the colour blue (Ambedkar-ism) prominently in them and the saffron ones of Haridev (and the lion’s face) are very reminiscent of Bal Thackeray’s Shiv Sena. The Periyar-inspired idea of Raavan as a ten-headed hero whose head is resurrected each time it is slain is used as a motif for Dalit struggles against the Rama iconography representing upper caste and class.
Kaala in Haridev's 'white' house 
(Image: https://scroll.in/reel/874368/rajinikanths-kaala-gets-u-a-certificate-no-clarity-yet-on-release-date)
But the finale/climax was most pregnant with meaning and held some promise for the future. Just like Raavan's head did, did Kaala come back to life by surviving the raging fire and the explosion? Ranjith doesn't make it clear whether that was real or an illusion! In an almost Modi-like pattern, the masses don Kaala's face as a mask, we see the villain decimated by the power of the organised masses and we see three colours run riot against and sully the crisp white of the villain (the pro-corporate political establishment) - black, blue and red. Is Pa. Ranjith clearly calling for a unity of three political forces, namely the Dravidian movement (black), the Dalit-Ambedkar movement (blue) and the communist movement (red)? Will Rajnikant the person, who is poised to take an actual plunge into electoral politics fit into this envisioned kaleidoscope or will he simply turn saffron-wards? We are left wondering...

Deepesh C

25 Nov 2017

Free individuals


We are all island balloons of individuality jostling about of our own free will, they say.
I doubt it very much; to me it appears that we are teeming bubbles bumbling from one to another item on unending to-do lists.
Yes, we live our lives entirely in those tiny whiffs of air between the exclamation mark of one item and the capital letter of the next. It is in these gaps that we breathe, and remember ourselves, and fill what we call life with the moments that become memories...
Cheers to the not-doing interims, to the 'nothingness' niches that are everything, to the unplanned slits on the large walls of neatly-planned busyness... Cheers to life!

20 Mar 2017

Book of Poems



She
Brought you a book of poems,
She, your new-found comrade,
As though present when all went by you,
And witnessing you when all went by her,
Through story-portions shared for days and days,
In moment after tired moment of fleeting camaraderie-building nostalgia,
Trapped by sheer word-crafted imagery.

The book
Caught hold of me with its soft, seeking, unhurting tentacles,
Coiling around me and lighting the dormant embers of word-lava
Lying as unheeded thought-seeds inside for years,
Waiting to burst open a thin excuse of a veneer,
And suddenly these thought-embers knock, bang, pound on the dusty fort-door
That lay shut, for no reason, like the routine shutting of creaky closing-hour doors
By the weary guard of a museum of history told ‘one fine next day’ that the monument
Is no longer to be visited, and worse still,
Is to be out of bounds, by decree, for no actual rhyme or reason…
...And now the flood-gates open, and the fire rages...!

5 Sept 2016

Religious Dogma and Change

Well, I have so many things on my mind. Let me put a few of those down here:
On Facebook, I see a lot of Sabarimala related posts, and a few posts about Mother Teresa and her sainthood. 
My thoughts: I am an atheist and so, I tend to feel detached from religious matters...unless they threaten lives. In matters where people protest and call for change, I am inclined to be on the side of science (as I know it) and morality (again my morality: including feminism, humanism...)...
And yet, my knowledge that my loved ones, who have different spiritual orientations and preferences, carry such an emotional depth and conviction in their hearts encourages me to desist from laughing at them, ridiculing them or from even motivating them, of my own volition, to change status quo. This, is not because I am a status-quoist! Anyone who knows me a bit, knows I'm all for change for the better. But, I know how religion and beliefs are held so close to the heart and can drive deep wedges between people. Also, I have seen my loved ones derive solace from their beliefs and faiths. When I cannot provide them alternate ways of succour, who am I to argue with them and drive them out of their idea of godliness?
In the same vein, I shall desist from 'asking' (for want of a more non-violent and neutral term) for women's entry into certain temples or for calling awards of sainthood as fraud though you may well guess what my stand on these matters are... By selecting outrage on certain issues, we run the danger of leaving out certain other issues which are more urgent and not taken.
Peace!

TEACHERS' DAY

On this day, I would like to do two opposite things: one, humbly pay tribute to all my teachers, right from my parents and grandparents, my teachers from early school years to the ones who taught me at university. A large part of what I am intellectually, politically and also as a human being is because of all my teachers. 
Two, more importantly, I would like to acknowledge the immense contribution of the early audience of my performances as a teacher - my classmates at school (KV BEML), who sat (or seemed to) with delight and encouraged me to perform . They suggested without saying it, that I would do well as a teacher and I joined RIE, Mysore, for a teaching degree.
When I did 'practice teaching' at Basel Mission school at Dharwad, the students sat with admiration... This too egged me on to surely take up teaching as a profession.
When I joined Sawan Public School, my first full-time teaching job, my dear colleagues were good role models for me, and my very dear students showed me the power of being a caring and loving teacher. The respect they still shower on me is without parallels in my life. I am most grateful to them for that.
When I joined DPS-Doha after that, my amazing students, apart from enjoying the informality I shared with them, showed me how rewarding it was to respect students as thinking individuals themselves, in a very Paulo Freirean way. The ideas of knowledge co-construction (Vygotskian perspectives) took seed in my mind here... Thanks to all of the amazing students I had there, some of who still remain active in discussions with me on diverse matters...
I carry the cumulative sum of all these micro-learning experiences in my heart and mind as a teacher at SSNCE now, and I still continue to learn from my students. A big collective thank you to all my students for the growth they showed, making me a proud teacher in reflected glory, and more importantly, for helping me grow as a teaching professional. Much love to all of u... I am a lucky teacher.
Disclaimer: By no means am I suggesting that I have reached the pinnacle of learning, as a teaching professional. Hardly... If I'm better today than in 1999, when I set out teaching, I owe a large part of this to my students. That's what I imply here. Cheers...!

4 Aug 2016

Un-othering

An amazing incident happened yesterday. I was riding a scooter in a lane near home, and I stopped at a turn when a child was playing in the middle of the road as his father was walking beside him. Seeing me on the scooter, his father caught hold of the child with a jerk and moved him to a side of the lane. He then said to me in a genuine apologetic tone, "I am sorry!"
I said to him in an accommodating, non-condescending way, "Please don't say sorry to me. This (the street) is as much his as it is mine..." The father was amazed, and probably rightly so. 
We live in a world filled increasingly with the idea of ownership. 'My', 'mine', 'myself' are the watchwords. We are all the time trying to prove to others or even to ourselves sometimes, that we are better than the others... The road is created for our convenience, the vehicles are there for our use, the vendors exist to sell wares to us. We are at the centre of our universes...
I, like all of us, need to reflect on this tendency of ours, and realize and remember, that we exist among others. We would be nothing without the others. As Bakhtin would probably say, my identity belongs to all - what I am is determined by what I am to others...
PS: I am glad I spontaneously said those words to the child's father... I want to be like that more and more! I hope I can...

Are we merely the sum of our parts?

At a time when we arrogate ourselves into believing that we are unitary beings and we are so full of ourselves and our abilities..., the 2013 film The Ship of Theseus, which I revisited now, makes us think about a few very basic questions:
- Who are you? Are you the sum of your various body parts?
- Can you really think you are an independent entity or are you truly a knot in the 'web of life'?
- Does someone else's organ in you (eyes for example) change every thing about you? Are you now the very same person? Are you somehow more plural now?
I quote the insightful opening lines of the film:
"As the planks of Theseus' ship needed repair, it was replaced part by part, up to a point where not a single part from the original ship remained in it, any more. Is it then, still the same ship?
If all the discarded parts were used to build another ship, which of the two, if either, is the real ship of Theseus?"
Simply brilliant, the message of the film, in terms of the questions it raises. The shots, the music and the sounds in the background... (Y)
So much more relevant in the context of Organ Donation day/week being organized, and in the situated memory of my dear younger brother we lost a few years ago, a few days before a kidney transplant procedure was due on him, on an otherwise-ordinary August (09/08) morning. Today (04/08) is his death anniversary as per the lunar calendar. My Achan and Amma are performing a ritual at their spiritual centre in the hope that his soul is at peace!